A Failed Mission


A Failed Mission

I write today out of utter frustration and deep concern over what appears to be a failed international mission into Haiti. Failure not just on the part the responding countries and the UN, but also on the part of the Haitian Government.

Why have no tents, tarps and aid have gone past Guiton on the North West coast? The only tarps in Bercy were purchased by those families who could afford them. Samaritans Purse tarps that were handed out in Port Au Prince that were then resold to others. Why didn’t Samaritans Purse or others bring tarps North West along the coast? Route 1 National is being traveled, I traveled in via Tap tap both to and from Bercy.


Yet another failure is the destruction of the Haitian market system through the handing out of aid. The farmer in the country side are suffering because know one is buying their crops. People are just going to the tent cities to get three meals a day. What about sustainability practices? Solar ovens (some of that has been done!), solar car battery charges (what most poor people use to power their homes), and most of all seeds to the farmers. Some day the flow of food is going to stop! What will people eat then? The farmers needs seeds, such as what I took in, to feed people in the coming months.

The villagers in Bercy repeatedly asked me “why hasn’t anyone come here? What happened to all the money that was donated? Why hasn’t anyone helped us?”

I am asking that question of you; why hasn’t that aid gone further? Why could a mother from Piermont NH bring in goods to help people when huge relief organizations haven’t/can’t/wont?

So how about shifting to a hand up and not a hand out? Teaching skills, providing needed equipment, and supports for the farmers, for the small business owners for the poor.


Updated April 20, 2010

U.N.’s Ballooning $732 Million Haiti Peacekeeping 

Budget Goes Mostly to Its Own Personnel

By George Russell  – FOXNews.com

 The United Nations has quietly upped this year’s peacekeeping budget for earthquake-shattered Haiti to $732.4 million, with two-thirds of that amount going for the salary, perks and upkeep of its own personnel, not residents of the devastated island.

The United Nations has quietly upped this year’s peacekeeping budget for earthquake-shattered Haiti to $732.4 million, with two-thirds of that amount going for the salary, perks and upkeep of its own personnel, not residents of the devastated island.

The world organization plans to spend the money on an expanded force of some 12,675 soldiers and police, plus some 479 international staffers, 669 international contract personnel, and 1,300 local workers, just for the 12 months ending June 30, 2010.

Some $495.8 million goes for salaries, benefits, hazard pay, mandatory R&R allowances and upkeep for the peacekeepers and their international staff support. Only about $33.9 million, or 4.6 percent, of that salary total is going to what the U.N. calls “national staff” attached to the peacekeeping effort.

Click here to see the supplementary budget document.

Presumably, the budget also includes at least part of some $10 million that the U.N. has spent on renting two passenger vessels, the Sea Voyager (known to some U.N. staffers as the “Love Boat“) and the Ola Esmeralda, for a minimum of 90 days each, as highly subsidized housing for some of its peacekeepers and humanitarian staff. The tab for the two vessels, which offer catered food, linen service and comfortable staterooms and lounges, is about $112,500 per day.

Under a cost-sharing formula, the U.S. pays a 27 percent share of the entire $732.4 million peacekeeping tab for Haiti during this 12 month period, or about $197.7 million.

The ultimate size of the peacekeeping bill for Haiti this year has been a source of much concern among the three dozen or so of the U.N.’s 192 members who pick up roughly 96 percent of the U.N.’s overall peacekeeping bill.

That concern rose sharply about a month ago, when U.N. Secretary General Ban Ki-moon’s office issued an updated peacekeeping estimate that used a $700 million figure strictly as a placeholder for the final Haiti post-quake number.

The new figures take some of the uncertainty out of that estimate, but even so, the U.N. was taking no chances of raising concerns higher with its new tally; rather than take a new vote on the expanded peacekeeper budget, the U.N. Secretariat simply issued its revised tally as an extension of the previous $611 million allotment it had voted for Haiti.

The Haitian peacekeeping budget is relatively unique among U.N. efforts, because there was no civil war or widespread bloodletting to inspire the original peacekeeping force, which arrived in 2004. Instead, the mission has mainly been intended to bolster political order in a society crushed by hurricanes, political turbulence, and grinding misery.

The revised peacekeeping tab is over and above the roughly $15 billion in short- and long-term aid that the international community — led by the U.S. and European Union — pledged to Haiti at an international donor’s conference last month.

It is also over and above the $773 million in humanitarian aid raised from donor nations and private citizens in a “flash” appeal in the days after the Jan. 12 earthquake — which is about half the total hoped for by the United Nations Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs when it raised the appeal.

Moreover, the revised Haiti peacekeeping budget only covers a period that ends in about 10 more weeks — on June 30, 2010 — at which time, Ban’s office will have to formulate another peacekeeping estimate for the stricken island, not to mention the remainder of its global peacekeeping effort.

Given the temporary nature of this year’s sudden 20 percent boost in Haiti peacekeeping costs, there is some possibility that next year’s budget will mark a decrease from the $732.4 million figure.

Since the U.N. installed peacekeepers on the island in 2004, however, the budgeted cost of peacekeeping has roughly doubled, from an original $372.8 million.

George Russell is executive editor of Fox News.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s